In the recent US midterm elections, an earthquake-level surprise emerged in Deep South Mississippi: A Democratic district attorney who’d challenged a sitting Republican Senator was running neck and neck with her, although the state hadn’t sent a Democrat to the Senate in 44 years. Pre-election polls had given the Democrat a less than 10 percent chance of unseating the Republican.
As votes were still being painstakingly counted, newspapers and TV stations carried the story that Scott Colom had gone to the lines of people waiting to get into a Trump rally and spoken to Trump supporters, changing minds of some of them. These reports had me picturing a cheeky candidate, possessing a magic tongue with persuasive power. What on earth had he said? I delved into the story further.
It turned out that Colom hadn’t delivered any sound-bite distillation of his campaign speeches to those in line. In fact, he hadn’t approached them with anything declarative at all. He approached them with questions asked in an open spirit. “What matters to y’all as voters? What are your top issues?” “What do you think about the tariffs?” “How do you feel about Flock cameras?” “Thank you for your service. What matters to you as a veteran right now?” He didn’t argue with the answers.
In short, what made the impact on those present at these interchanges was that he listened.
Let’s go deeper into the power of finely tuned listening and why it can be more transformative than speaking. Consider these two factors:
Putting aside preconceptions. Superb listening entails dropping your armor and walls, letting go of your judgments and projections, setting your own pain, hopes, beliefs and values to one side. In the video clips I watched, I saw Colom not approaching the ideologically opposite folks in line by steeling himself to talk to evil beings. Instead, he seemed easy-going, friendly and above all, receptive. Even for politicians, such approachability is difficult to fake.
Adopting an attitude of curiosity, respect and empathy. Effective listening also requires being present, clearing one’s mind and behavior of distractions and forging a genuinely personal, in-the-moment exchange. This means someone is not going through the motions while staying alert for where they could insert their own agenda. They are engaged and responsive, not following a behavioral formula, such as nodding and restating, that is reputed to lead to their desired outcome. Communication flows.
Recent research indicates that neither introverts nor extroverts outdo others in the capacity to listen. I’m highly skeptical of that study, because it included enthusiastic responses and conversational validation of the other person (probably more characteristic of extroverts) as measures of good listening. The study relied on behavioral performances of appearing to listen, which don’t necessarily reveal someone’s true receptivity or intake of information.
Most of all, that study didn’t capture the significance we assign to listening when we say “He heard, but he didn’t listen” or “I warned her, but she wouldn’t listen” – listening as heeding or acting accordingly. The researchers also didn’t note whether or not the audience felt heard because of someone listening, which to my mind is the greatest possible result.
Although I didn’t follow Scott Colom’s earlier campaign, I suspect that this last, very important sense of “listen” partly accounts for why he outperformed expectations, ultimately winning the Senate race. I’m guessing he approached voters throughout his state without preconceptions, asked what they cared about and made their answers the centerpiece of his speeches. After all, if he asked for voter input and then ignored what came at him, he wouldn’t have come so strongly from behind. One article I read mentioned that he held over 60 town hall meetings during his campaign – a format that at its best serves as a vehicle for listening.
And I hope further studies will probe whether, with our liking of conversational pauses, our penchant for less small talk and our inclination to think before we speak, we introverts do in fact pay better attention to others when we interact with them.
Related posts
Introvert Superpower #2: Listening

